9/18/12.
Paul McHugh, M.D.:
"IN THE WAKE of September 11, what can a psychiatrist contribute to America's
defense? Nothing, of course, to defend the nation from bombs, but something
perhaps to defend it against confusion--and here America certainly needs help.
At the University of Pennsylvania, the provost called several
neuroscientists together to consider whether the terrorists should be viewed as
bad or mad: evildoers or sufferers from an exculpating mental disease. The group
reached no conclusion, but one participant thought "brain images" might give the
answer.
Editorialists argued about whether the atrocities should be
considered acts of war or crimes. The blame-America-first group wanted the
events called crimes and proposed prosecutions at the Hague. Some even opposed
military retaliation, concerned that it would kill innocent people, produce
martyrs, and generate recruits to the terrorist cause, along with endless war.
One distinguished Boston psychiatrist, speaking to anchorman Peter
Jennings on ABC, explained the emotional distress of Americans as castration
anxiety provoked by seeing the destruction of these two "phallic symbols" on the
tip of Manhattan and suggested more psychoanalytic insight for us all.."
http://ontology.buffalo.edu/smith/courses01/rrtw/McHugh.htm